General assumption in developing countries like India is that national interest covers only national security, military and diplomacy. In limited cases trade and economic treaties are considered. Rarely 'technology' is factored in. Even, if it were, policy analysts and policy makers concentrate on military technologies or other 'dual use' technologies like nuclear and missiles. In reality 'technology' in various other civilian sectors are equally critical as national interest issue. Countries like India which depend predominantly on imported technologies and know how for their economic growth need to acquire some minimum endogenous technological capabilities for at least for parts of products and services. A set of view graphs presented at ICRIER recently provide policy approach for actions.



A few months ago media was going berserk over the deaths of many inmates of a beggar home in Bangalore. Many viewer responses were SMS’ed to TV screens were to the effect: How can an IT super city allow this to happen? Govt. and politicians were once again came under public “whipping”.

Yes it is sad when people die. Death of poor people in India gets buried under gross statistics. Hunger of poor people gets lost in public debates by well fed Indians. Discussions over food security bill make a sad reading. Passed, in whatever form, it is likely to get buried under the dreary deserts of our public administration.

Why? Are our administrators by their very nature, callous, heartless thieves? Incapable, incompetent idiots?

I am not going to pass a jugdement. But I am going to analyze the issues concerning the Bangalore Beggar Home and raise some questions which were not raised in the reams of newspaper columns or in TV bytes. You can then come to your own conclusions.

First and foremost whatever happened of the Bangalore Beggar Home? It very much exists and being run or not run in the same old ways. What about enquiries? Files have a unique speed. No doubt the cases will be examined and kept hanging for years.

What about the great public (middle class) indignation? All gone and shifted to Common Wealth Games (CWG), Vedanta, Posco clearances to Adarsh Housing and now taken over Obama visit. Now 2G… Waiting to shift somewhere else…. The sad fact for our governance is the gullible middle class memory. Middle class finds great entertainment in the high moral frenzy exhibited by media.

Solve all India’s problems through e-mails, SMS’s, TV debates (with millions of zombies watching and texting), great scholarly columns in newspapers…. This has become the pattern over the past two decades especially… Just because more channels are available. In good old decades before, such a process was done through gossips in office, homes and social functions.

The tone of every critic or speaker is to take a high moral ground. How can even one beggar die of hunger? Hang all of them responsible for it!

Let us look at the root causes of the Bangalore Beggar Home. Several years ago some well intentioned persons decided to keep Bangalore a presentable city and keep the beggar menace away… Beggars are a national a shame; also bad examples of lazy living. At least let us keep the garden city away from the menace. So they get an Act passed. Begging in Bangalore is a crime. Persons who beg can be punished by law. So an aesthetic value or a moral indignation against begging is given a legal tooth.

When we (my wife and I) moved to Bengaluru last November to stay in our only home, NALANDA, one old person, familiar to me, during a conversation was telling so many wrong and cruel things what “powerful persons” do in Bengaluru. This is a great Indian pastime from Kashmir to Kanyakumari, from Nagaland to Rajasthan! I told him why don’t you talk about it openly or write about it. His response was “Sir! I could be caught any time and put into a beggar’s home, as I look frail and am with ordinary clothes!”… It looked like a joke then, as the conversation drifted somewhere else as it happens with many such conversations! 

I realized the significance of what he said when the Bangalore Beggar home stories broke out in press. One article had traced well the anti – beggar act, the establishment of beggar home etc. The power of the State being given so easily to govt. easily through Acts which stand on moral grounds, have corrupted the law enforcement agencies. Fringe elements in them can use the same laws to trouble innocent people, even while the law concerned solves no problems!

Can any one of you say boldly that there are no beggars in Bengaluru?

It is our hoary tradition that every holy place (of all religions in India) is full of beggars. People give alms and feel relieved that they have done some punya. Gurudwaras are usually an exception because there is a long tradition of langar – any one can come and eat food in the mornings, afternoon and evenings. No body needs to be hungry. Hundreds of poor in the local areas can live on it for days together. But most other places, it is different. 

Let us also look at the root causes of begging. A part from a tradition that does not look at it as demeaning, there is a large number of poor Indians. The vagaries of the weather makes them lose them meager incomes. (Shame to the Indian economists, scientists, technologists, policy makers and administrators who run the country – there are workable solution needing no new research and are being implemented by many countries). Also serious health problems to an earning member of poor family can knock them out of even subsistence levels.

Thanks to the Indian democracy, they can move out in search of some wage earnings. When they don’t get earning they beg too. Of course, there are some who have made begging a profession. I have seen organized begging in Bombay during the late 1950’s and 1960’s when I was going to school and college.

But when economic opportunities are available to people to earn a reasonable income, most people will avoid begging. Till then the society and the state has no right to penalize begging. If you arrest a few of them and put them in a beggar home, then another flock of people will come from different parts of Karnataka and the neighboring states. Is there a way to stop them? Except by cruel means!

Coming back to running of a beggar home by Govts, during an initial hype land is acquired, nice buildings are built (some times even without corruption involved in such construction!). Then the impulse subsides. No funds are given for maintenance which comes under the govt. budgets called non – plan. Economists will like to keep the non – plan component of the govt. expenditure down to the minimum and increase the plan component which is for development – that is new projects aimed at new growth or societal good areas.

Therefore most govt. organizations or projects after the initial establishment, are left out as part starving orphans. That is why many roads are in disrepair. Many school suffer… This is the basic reasons.. Of course over the past several decades, building upon the theme of scarce non – plan funds, corrupt elements have crept in. Leave every thing unattended till they become a crisis. Even the available meager non – plan funds need not be spent efficiently or if possible extract some “corruption money” out of those purchases or contracts as well.

This has become the pattern.

So we transition very soon from a moralistic law to corrupt beggar home.

Look at so many things around your area built on the premise of high moral ground with the power of law: Pollution control agencies, sections dealing with anti – dowry in govt;. you can count them yourselves.

Lessons in governance I have derived during the past few decades specially is that we have to knock out all the unrealistic laws and the resulting empowerment of the State and its enforcing officials. Let us have only such laws which can be compatible with our society and which can be implemented fully. For higher moral principles, let govt. projects or philanthropic projects be undertaken without the power of law but using the power of emulation.           

One crucial governance issue before the nation is to creatie opportunities for productive employment and income generation for the millions of poor and also preparing them in advance with necessary skills. This has to be a continual process.

Are we ready? Especially the now powerful and vocal middle class? Or should we be inventing or discovering a Satan every week for national flogging through media?







Y S Rajan

 The first Professor Satish Dhawan Commemoration lecture organized by The Institution of Engineers (India) (IE), Karnataka State Centre to be delivered on 22nd September 2010 at The Institution of Engineers (India), Karnataka State Centre, No. 3, Dr. B R Ambedkar Veedhi, Bangalore 560 001.

Dr. Radhakrishnan, Chairman, ISRO /Secretary, DOS / Chairman, Space Commission, Dr. L V Muralikrishna Reddy, Chairman, The Institution of Engineers (India) Karnataka Sate Centre, Dr. S B Ganjigatti, Honorary Secretary and distinguished participants.



It is indeed a great honour and unique privilege for me to be given the opportunity to deliver the first Professor Satish Dhawan Commemoration lecture remembering Professor Satish Dhawan(whose 90th birth anniversary is on September 25, 2010) a great teacher, distinguished researcher, an unparalled leader and administrator of academic institutions and scientific and technology organizations, and above all a committed engineer in heart and real life.  The institutions he built are shining before us. For me it is a special memory as much of my life from 1973 was influenced and shaped by him.  Our relationship is several combinations of his being Guru, Mentor, Guide, Boss and many more.

True to the tradition in which he has moulded many of us for several years, I am not going to dwell on his life and his contributions to science, technology, engineering, management, economy and society.  There are only a few writings on him.  I would refer to two recent articles.  One by me: Bibliographical memories of the Indian National Science Academy (INSA, Vol. 28, 2005) which gives the earlier references and draws from a few unique writings by him post-retirement.  Another is a brilliant piece in the Hindu last year on 25th September 2009 by Dr. Manoranjan Rao.


The crucial role of engineering for modern civilization is implicit in every aspect of our lives.  Rapid progress in the development of the country post-independence has taken place through the application of engineering to different sectors: dams and irrigation systems which paved the way for green revolution; roads, civil construction of many types including building of major cities; sanitation systems; manufacturing industries; transport systems from trucks, buses, trains, ships, aircrafts, shipyards and airports, pharmaceutical industries, one can list many more.

However, the unique role of engineering, got submerged in the romance of the word “science” used by Jawaharlal Nehru who meant it in a broader sense of generation, acquisition and application of modern knowledge as well as a rational way of looking at life, which he termed as scientific temper.

 So much so, the prestigious Indian science academies ignored the achievers in engineering discipline and even engineering researchers.  This led to the formation of Indian National academy of Engineers (INAE).

Prof.  S Dhawan did not like such a separation even while he was clear about their different roles.  Science and engineering intertwine and feed each other.  Building of a new improved observing equipment or instrument is an engineering activity.  But it can help many new discoveries.  Chandrayaan-1 is a great engineering feat of ISRO engineers and technicians and their partners from industries.  It also helps first rate science.  Similarly some new scientific discovery can pave way for new engineering activities. Prof S Dhawan ensured that the personnel policy of ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) does not create such a separation and dichotomy, as is so in many of our scientific and technology establishments.  He went even to the detail of the designation of each individual professional in ISRO as Scientist/Engineer, SC, SD, SE…….G, H etc., Every one carries both the titles, irrespective of the basic degree he/she caries.

 But the national science policy makers and public system in general ignored the role of engineering and somehow assumed that scientific research alone would suffice and would automatically lead to further developments in industry, agriculture etc.   Results of such a negligence was clear with continued and repeated import of technology, engineering drawings and consultancy services by industry in public and private sector.  Then these policy makers started using a word “Technology”.  â€œTechnology Policy” since 1983 started emphasizing more on the research aspects of engineering and forgetting the crucial role of “engineering” which is the delivery of products and services to he society and people and thus growing the economy.

Around mid 1990’s the word’ technology” almost  exclusively got “hijacked” by IT sector!  Later the celebration of technology got symbolized by a high-tech event.  It was, of course, a great engineering event with high intensity of scientific knowledge, important in itself for the country.

But engineering (and therefore technology) is much more inclusive and pervasive of all sectors and all walks of human endeavor.  Where ever there is an actual delivery of goods and services, engineering has to come in.  No wonder most of our youngsters rush for engineering degrees as in the final analysis industries or government agencies responsible for development have to deliver goods and services.

Even so, it is necessary for the country to recognize “Engineering” as a crucial discipline.  Then alone a strong foundation for all round national development can take place. Present growth in the industrial and services sector is predominantly based on borrowed technologies ranging from engineering designs, drawings, know-how and above all heavy import of embodied technologies (and engineering) through import of machinery, equipment, software etc.

It is important in this context, to dwell upon some of the definitions of technology, science and engineering etc., and understand the distinctions as well. 

Thereafter, we will briefly describe two major engineering challenges given by Prof. S Dhawan in one of his later speeches.  After that we will touch upon a mega-challenge for the country, the people, society and the economy as a whole, which needs immediate, attention by the engineering community.


And how they relate to economy society and people?  Also how they are interlinked?  It is better to see a few quotes from the address Sir David Davies.  (Sir David Davies, “Engineering as an Innovator of change in Society and the Role of Engineering Academies”, address by Sir David Davies, CBE, F Eng. FRS, Chief Adviser to the Ministry  of Defence, UK and President, the Royal Academy of Engineering, at the annual Function of the Indian National Academy of Engineering (INAE).  New Delhi, December 3, 1998).

About Science: “Science is unquestionably a search for a better understanding of the laws of nature described in the broadest possible sense from astronomy to medicine and from engineering to genetics.  Despite massive steps forward in each field, the understanding always remains incomplete….”

About Engineering: “Engineering on the other hand is about innovation, design and the construction of new products and new capabilities.  We must take care not to define this solely in terms of physical products since engineering can also often offer new services often  without the need for additional hardware………”. However, whatever the form of the new innovation its design is inevitably a compromise between many different parameters.  The success of the products is therefore bound up with the efficiency of the design process which has the role of matching the design to the requirements in as efficient a way as possible…” .

What is innovation?: “In terms of an engineering product or service an innovation enables it to offer some new advantage in capability or performance (including cost) that there is a strong coupling between engineering and science but this does not necessarily mean that this engineering innovation derives directly from the latest improvements or understanding in scientific theories……..”.

An example: “Perhaps the most obvious example here is the steam engine.  That innovation arose from experimental observation but is was not based upon any current understanding a theory of heat at the time. Indeed the whole subject of thermodynamics was developed afterwards.  It provided better understanding of the performance of heat engines and was further evolved in order to aid the design of improved equipment”.

For Sir David Davies the word technology and engineering are synonymous. In the later part of his talk he has discussed the role of Engineering Academies (I would place the Institution of Engineers also as one, though it may not have been very active in terms of new and innovative engineering aspects recently).  He points out that for the implementation of most of the Government policies for various social and economic sectors the strong link required is engineering (technology).  Policies have to link to engineering aspects in the implementation. He has implied that without such strong links most policy statements may not achieve the stated goals.

You may judge for yourselves what has happened in India over the past six decades and why the Indian performance lags seriously behind the policy and programme statements.

Another quote about the definition of technology and technology policy by Lewis M. Branscomb, Empowering technology: implementing a US strategy edited by LMB, 1993, MIT Press emphasizes this point again: “A technology is the aggregation of capabilities, facilities, skills, knowledge, and organization required to successfully create a useful service or product.  Technology policy concerns the public means for nurturing those capabilities and optimizing their applications in the service of national goals and the public interest”.

The word technology here encompasses engineering and the processes of engineering.

The boundaries which distinguish technology (engineering) policy from economic and industrial policy are fuzzy at best.  It is therefore necessary for Engineers and Engineering Academies or Institutions not to be quiet spectators or  mere implementers of policies done elsewhere but to be proactive shapers of various socio-economic-trade and industrial policies.  I have elaborated in detail the interplay of these policies in my book “Empowering Indians with economic, business, and technology strengths for the 21st century” (2001, revised print 2002).

It is with this spirit and a special appeal, I outline there major tasks which the Engineering community can give attention to.  To be sure India needs many more such mega engineering tasks but I give these three important ones as illustrations due to limitations of time. One of these tasks is for medium term; second is for very very long term (these two are drawn from Prof. S  Dhawan’s address “Whither Space and Astronautics,” delivered at the Astronautical Society of India Bangalore, September 6,1996) and the third one is for immediate action and just – now (already too late!) type of  attention and implementation.



The National Early Warning and Response System (NEWARS) This useful and grand idea was proposed by Prof Satish Dhawan about 14 years ago and he was passionate about it.  Being an engineer and par excellence programme manager he built the system (programme) design around the existing and proven systems established by ISRO especially the National Natural Resources Management System (NNRMS) and Indian National Satellites (INSAT) system, though the scale, scope and complexity of NEWARS will be much greater.  In his words as in the address quoted earlier “Consolidation, extension and systematic utilization of what has been accomplished in the last 15 years of NNRMS and INSAT logically leads to NEWARS  - a Space Based Early Warning and Response System which would collect timely information on all major aspects of national life which have a strong coupling with and depend upon protection and effective use of natural and organized human resources.  The system goes well beyond information collection and dissemination and seeks to feed and nurture not only organized sectors of public life but also create awareness, initiative and action among wide sections of rural and urban India”.

He explains in detail how NEWARS can develop without seeking to displace the existing systems and tune them into a comprehensive network in stages.

While the current systems are useful and really touch the lives of people in many beneficial ways, there are still many gaps in giving early warning/alerts which can reach village groupings or urban areas, in providing real time monitoring as well as in receiving the (ultimate) user feedback on issues concerning their lives.

The main areas to be covered by NEWARS include:

-              Agriculture

-              Geology

-              Plants & Forests

-              Soils

-              Industry & Mining

-              Ecology & environment

-              Urbanization

-              Transport & Energy sectors etc.,


Note etc., etc., which is from his lecture.

In addition to several useful early warnings and post event information such as crop stress, water/moisture availability, pest formation, crop yield forecast, post harvest crop yield estimates etc., in “Agriculture” sector: and similarly for other items listed above, he envisaged the following benefits as well:

“NEWARS encompass all the above elements and one can envisage in addition during the course of growth

Smuggling – Land & Sea                         -      Loss to the economy

-     Distress to fisher &farm folk

-     Illegal intrusions into Indian Territory

Large Scale community gatherings       -          Pilgrimage areas (Oct 29, 1995)

Amarnath-Sabarimalai-Kurukshetra    10 lakh persons Holy Dip_

Sravanabelagola                                               A million visit Sabarimalai

Holy fairs of Sangams                          Accidents, illness etc.,

Population migrations             -           Bangladesh displaced.  Biharis driven

towards Delhi

Large scale Epidemics             -           Induced by Natural/Man made disasters/

                                                                        Spread of VIRUS etc.,

Insurgency & Terrorists                       -           Disruptive of Civil life

& National Security                             -           India’s borders and within the country.”


He points out the crucial element of NEWARS as: “It is in the transformation of the acquired data/information into a variety of practically useful forms that the challenge lies”.

Look at the huge engineering challenge before us.  NEWARS is something that can be executed in about 3 decades if several private and public sector institutions industries and NGOs join together. Engineering community can take the lead, as NEWARS can help make most engineering efforts environment friendly and people friendly.  And also help a true democratic participation in development and growth.  Would persons from Bangalore chapter of Institution of Engineers like to take the lead along with institutions and industries here as well as with the help of state of Karnataka and ISRO?   No doubt government money is required for building up the system and maintaining it.  But if creative administrative and financial policies and procedures are adopted, it is possible to intertwine very effectively private commercial operators as well along with some user fees for some sectors.  Such a government-private-public participation will reduce the government budgetary support.


I leave it here and go to another great engineering challenge “larger in scope, scale and time frame requiring participation in international multi disciplinary research with the inevitable geopolitics and uncertainties” that is in the next section.




 Basically he has described the following elements:

“First some definitions:

Ecopoleses – A term coined by R Haynes from the Greek (The words Greek root means the making of a home) it implies the fabrication of an ecosystem or biosphere on a lifeless plant.

Planetary Engineering -      Implies application of engineering and scientific principles to planets to change them to suit human purposes.

Terra Forming - implies creation of an Aerobic Biosphere on another planet, suitable for humans and higher animals – in effect a second inhabitable Earth”

Prof Dhawan also cautions as in the following:

“Before briefly seeing what would be involved in Planetary Engineering we note that serious ethical questions have been raised:

a)                 Is it morally justified for man to change the climate & environment of another planet?

b)                 If life exists on the planet has man the right to modify the ecosystem to suit humans? This may harm the life forms there/a problem man has encountered on Earth & is yet to fully understand & solve

c)                 If no life exists on the planet is it right to change the conditions to suit earth based life?”

He has then described in detail as to what is involved in transforming a planet and given an example for performing such a mission for Mars.  He has posed a number questions from an engineering and project management view points.


This engineering mission is ridden with intellectual and aspirational challenges which you can all carry with you and transmit to subsequent generations.

I would like end this section with a quote from the end part of Prof S Dhawan’s address:

“One may ask: can the advent into space provide a moral and practical substitute for WAR?  War between people and also Man’s war on the ECO SYSTEM?  can exploring the Solar System fulfill a psychological need & also unify Mankind?

Civilizations have for long sought answers to problems of existence. In the last half a century it has slowly dawned on mankind that of the great variety of life forms on the earth, one of them Homosapiens- has reached a stage when its actions are endangering the Globe.  The Skeptics asks:  What is the moral justification for exploring the Planets & Stars when there is so much Hunger, misery, Poverty & Strife on earth?  The optimist says: Programmes which focus on space and encounter complex issues of survival in a hostile environment, facing unexpected dangers &situations & overcoming them – enhance Man’s capability to faced the unknown & survive as a truly civilized being.

Collectively can mankind enhance its capabilities to evolve a civilization on earth which is more humane, sensitive and harmonious not only to humans but to all forms of life?  If yes, then we go into space to understand & resolve problems of life on earth


After describing these two Mega tasks derived from Prof. Satish Dhawan’s address, I would like to emphasize that the first one NEWARS is with us and we can develop it at a pace desired by all of us.  It will be immensely useful in taking the benefits science, technology, engineering and other knowledge systems directly to the people of India.  It is a great engineering challenge.  It comprises mostly known elements and nearly proven elements.  The challenge is to put them together.

Now I would describe the third Mega task which is crucial for our economy, society and people.  It is an item needed by all.  It is something fully in the domain of engineering except for policy making on some aspects.



We have all heard an old saying: “Water water everywhere but no water to drink”. Most of us are familiar with the news of flooding and resultant damages in many parts of our country about two times in per year. We also read reports about severe water shortage for many crops. In the cities including metros we have continuous year round flow of large sewage systems even while there is a drinking water shortage in almost all cities.

Science, technology, engineering and academic institutions have neglected a holistic look at the solutions to the water problem. Most of the media with some exceptions would like to highlight only scenarios water wars, or flood or drought or drying lakes or pollution by industries or romantic solutions of rain water harvesting or issues of water rights etc. We get excited at the news of finding some water on Moon! Very little attention has gone in terms of available engineering solutions in terms of maximizing efficiency in the use of water, conserving existing water resources, recycling the waste water for repeated reuse and above all continual maintenance of  water related engineering systems which is crucial for the sustainability. The latter requires a lot of awareness and training of the users – ordinary citizens to households to farmers to industry persons, as well.

In order to have a clear perspective of the dimensions of the issues relating to water, true to the scientific and engineering traditions, let us look at some numbers. I have drawn them primarily from two excellent reports / books.

i.      Integrated Water Resource Development – A Plan for Action,

Report of The National Commission for Integrated Water Resources Development, 

Government of India, Ministry of Water Resources,

New Delhi, September, 1999


ii.     State of the Indian Farmer,

A Millennium Study

Volume 3, Water Resources,

K.V.Raju, A.Narayanamoorthy, Govind Gopakumar, H.K.Amarnath

Ministry of Agriculture – Government of India (2004)

New Delhi

Major sources of water are rain, and surface water supplemented by ground water. Some data on them are as under. (From Report (i) above)

(a)   All India average rainfall is 1,170 mm, but it varies respectively from 100 to 11,000 mm in Western deserts to North Eastern region. More than 50 percent of precipitation takes place in about 15 days and less than 100 hours altogether in a year. The rainy days may be only about five in deserts to 150 in the North East.

(b)  Average annual precipitation in India including snowfall has been estimated as 4,000 km³. We have estimated the total annual water resources of the country (including both surface water and ground water) as 1,953 km³. Some of this originate beyond our borders, and in turn some of it cross our borders on its way to the sea and goes into downstream countries.

Another factor in terms of per capita utilization:

India, which has 2.45 percent of the world’s land resources, has roughly 4 percent of the world’s fresh water resources, whereas the country’s population is 16 percent of the world’s population.

Total availability as per Report (i) above is:

“It has been estimated by this commission that as against a total annual availability of 1,953 km³ (inclusive of 432 km³ of groundwater), approximately 690 km³ of surface water and 396km³ from groundwater resources, making a total of 1,086 km³, can be put to use. So far, a quantum of about 600 km³ only out of this available water, has been put to use. However, pollution problems have been growing, posing a serious threat to availability for use. Municipal sewage (often untreated), urban and rural wastes, industrial effluents, chemical fertilizers and pesticides, have all contributed to the pollution of both surface water and groundwater. At the same time, the demand for water will grow with population growth and the processes of economic development. It has been estimated  that the available supplies on certain premises will be matched if not exceeded by demand by the year 2050. Water – stress conditions will be experienced in many parts of the country unless remedial measures are taken in time.”

There are some marginal differences of number between the two reports.

From report (ii) let us look at the sectoral utilization of the water. Of the 180Mham of surface run – off, 15Mham is stored in reservoirs and various tanks: The loss due to evaporation is about 40% in shallow storage places and 20% in deep reservoirs (on the whole about 5Mham is lost). About 15Mham of the river flow is utilized directly or by pumping. Remaining 150Mham flows into sea or adjoining countries. Ground water resources that are periodically replenished amount to 67Mham of which 13Mham are utilized for various sectors.

Of the total utilization of water resources (described above) amount to 38Mham of this.

o   35Mham goes for irrigation (11Mham from ground water and 24Mham from surface water)

o   3Mham are utilized for other purposes, predominantly domestic, industries, and power generation.

There are variations in these estimates see table below from the Report (ii), (Units Mham)














CWC, 1995







Reddy, 1992







CWC, 2000







CWC, 2000


            One thing is clear even amid these variations. Irrigation is the bulk user. Domestic and industrial uses are almost equal.


            Intersectoral projection of water demand for coming years from Report (ii) is in table below. Units of water in km³.
















World Bank




















World Bank




















World Bank












Source: MoWR, 1999a; World Bank; Seckler et al., 1998.


            Having looked at some of the above macro – data let us look at the percentage of the Net irrigated area to Net sown area taken from Report (ii)


Size Class

1970 – 71

1975 – 76

1980 – 81

1985 – 86

1990 – 91

ACGR (%)

Marginal (< 1 ha)







Small (1-2 ha)







Semi-Medium (2-4ha)







Medium (4-10 ha)







Large (> 10 ha)







All Size Class














It shows the continuing gross inequity in use of water for agricultural use. No wonder most Indian farmers are abysmally poor and therefore India is poor (since about 65% of Indian s depend upon agriculture – we need to change this figure drastically. That has been dealt with by me elsewhere and I won’t talk about it here).

The total availability of water resources, per capita possibility etc indicate the challenge to eradicate this inequity and make available good irrigation (i.e. enough water to the plants at right times) is not expansion as usual but it is an engineering challenge. Engineers have to work with agricultural experts and local communities to make them learn and use water saving systems, use the recycled water, maintain the facilities, and to keep a vigil on new polluting sources and give solutions for them, etc.

It is difficult to cover comprehensively all aspects of engineering / technology / project management tasks required for this Mega Task – 3. If one considers locale specific aspects then the complexity becomes more. For example water conservation aspects relating to agriculture in Punjab will be different from that required for Rajasthan. Hence the engineering considerations will be different. So with different sectors and sizes of industries etc. Therefore we will attempt to have a broad profile of various critical aspects of this Mega Task – 3 on Water. Engineering professionals can expand on these elements when they actually get into action mode.



As discussed earlier the source can be from static surface water, flowing surface water (run off, rivers, canals etc), ground water, rain water collection and recycled water.

Of the water sources, the ones which are monitored well are the 81 major reservoirs; as of the first week of September 2010, the water in these 81 reservoirs was about 103 billion m³ (32% more than last year). A good news for the Ministry of Power as the hydroelectric power will be good this year. Some places may have threat of flooding, when the reservoirs cross danger levels!

But when we consider the water sources for most of India monitoring these 81 is not enough. One needs monitoring of river flows and importantly many small – medium – large lakes. On paper we have a system in the country. Many of you will know the inadequacy.

A project to have a regular monitoring of surface water, their quantity and quality will be a great engineering challenge. One element of NEWARS described earlier can help putting such a system into operation. A combination of remote sensing and data collection platforms which can be accessed by local mobile telephones or by satellites, can form an effective monitoring system. Such a data available on a national portal can be of great help. I am not unaware of security concerns that can be raised by some persons. In the current period with high resolution satellite imagery available globally and mobile phones which can take pictures and transmit globally, such worries are at best naïve or paranoid.

Well, it is not just enough to record and to monitor all of them, though it could be a first parallel step.

All the major and minor reservoirs, rivers, lakes etc require serious attention in terms of desilting. That will conserve precious water resources.

Let us not for a moment waste our attention on reducing the evaporative losses. May be in future after we finish the simpler and large quantity tasks.

An important issue in conserving the water resources is to keep them clean. Most lakes are full of algae, hyacinths and other plants if they have not dried up already. Many others become easy places to dump solid wastes or the sewage and waste water. This is so even in rural areas. Even the “lost” (due to human apathy) lakes need to be recovered, as much as possible.

Engineers in local areas (under a major project catalyzed and spearheaded by IE’s several chapters in India) can very much help in this process.

Similarly one needs to monitor all the ground water usage points. With local help and modern communication (mobile, telephone and satellite) technologies, it is not a difficult task.

Then there are other areas like wetlands, marshy lands etc. they need preservation too, for ecological balance.

Rain water harvesting is another useful water source. But this needs to be done with some caution. Somehow in our country we seem to have an implicit faith in things which were used several centuries ago. While rain water harvesting is good, in the distant past we had very little human and cattle population. Also other newer technologies were not available, not even deep ground drilling.

Indiscriminate rain water harvesting in rain scarce areas may stop downstream flows and affect the ecology at a distance. (Remember how oasis in a desert gets formed). More importantly the indiscriminate decentralization of rain water harvesting to the household levels in big cities like Delhi etc. are one of the cause of spread of mosquito borne diseases. In bigger cities we need to rethink rain water collection strategies. We need to use the storm – water flow channels to aggregate in a local area and have good engineering practices to store and re-use. It is sad that in many housing layouts and also in cities, the storm water channels are being converted into sewage channels.

Again coming back to water sources, their use and reuse are vital to conserve their use. It is possible to use the existing resources to give sufficient per capita water for all Indians for various uses listed before. Let us examine some of the water use technologies.



In its simplest form, they are micro irrigation systems mostly operating in villages – often not even constructed by govt. agencies. Most of these areas belong to the unirrigated part of agricultural statistics quoted earlier.

Due to the drinking water mission, some of these areas may have a ground water hand pump – some working, some defunct. Otherwise traditional wells, small ponds etc are there. During rains they fill better especially helping the cattle. The fields of the marginal and small farmer receive rain directly and through micro – irrigation channels.

Due the costs involved, it is difficult to imagine that all these unirrigated areas are covered through good water supply and irrigation systems as in the “green revolution” areas of agriculture (about 1/3rd of the total irrigated area).

This is where the real first challenge to the Indian engineer lies. Use of modern plastic liners can reduce wasteful leakages; also drip or sprinkler systems can reduce the need for water to the minimum but capital costs can be higher; some govt. funds are available. Also single local pump systems can be used… many more ways to reach water; I am not unaware of the poor electricity supply in most areas.

In recent USAID conference titles “Transforming Development through Science, Technology and Innovation” (July 13 – 14, 2010) held at Washington D.C, for which I was a special invitee, the background papers indicated that a Grand Challenge in Development at a global level to fight against poverty is as under:

Reduction of agricultural water consumption in non – arid and semi – arid regions of Africa by 70%, with an increase in agricultural yields over 5 years.

What is told here for Africa is applicable to most parts of rain fed, unirrigated arid and semi – arid agricultural regions for India.

The engineering challenge would need work with farmers, agricultural experts, technology developers, energy source providers, NGO’s etc.

I have placed it first because it affects most people of India (about 40 to 50%) and the challenge is to work with water sources available nearby and at a low cost, which can be used productively and cost effectively.



Major use of water is in the upper end agriculture – irrigated 1/3rd of agricultural area. (We have seen the statistics earlier). In these areas, water use is often extravagant so much so it makes the soils go saline along with the fertilizers and chemicals which float upwards. It is essential to devise engineering methods against such a water – wastage. In addition, such an agriculture which takes away almost 70% of used water in India, waste water not recycled. It is sent away from the fields along with agro – chemicals which further pollute many downstream water bodies.

It is necessary to work with farmers and local governments, convince them and have recycling plants set up near their village. Also reuse the recycled water. In Israel about 80% of water used for agriculture is recycled and used. They are increasing the percentage. In Spain it is about 35%.

A bigger sociological challenge is because water is given free or practically free to most of these farmers, who are relatively rich and influential.

I am reminded of the experience of India’s greatest engineer Bharat Ratna Sir M.Visvesvaraya in the Poona Irrigation District, when he was posted in April 1899. Among many books by him and on him, I will refer to one: Memories of My Working Life (written by him 1951) published by Karnataka Engineers Association and Karnataka Engineering Service Association (2001). It has 158 pages. I am amazed at the range of water works he has done all over India (even the present areas of Pakistan)! It is a book worth reading by all engineers interested in water works. It will inspire them to go through the variety of challenges successfully. His works post retirement were huge and immense. So those who are retired or nearing retirement may look at such major possibilities around water.



Most villages in India have about two ponds. Punjab has about 13,000. Dr.R.Venkataraman former Chief Engineer, ISRO and who is a part of the fraternity of IE, had taken up a major task for advising the then Punjab Govt. (2000 – 2001) on many water related issues referred to the office of Principal Scientific Adviser (then Dr.Kalam) and TIFAC(Technology Information, Forecasting & Assessment Council). I being the chief executive of TIFAC and Scientific Secretary PSA office, had been closely associated with them. The village ponds which existed for centuries had to support about 5 times more human population and also much bigger sized cattle. Naturally the sewage and the cattle wastes find their way to the ponds. BOD (Biological Oxygen Demand) levels (we had them measured for several of them) were intolerable.

A plan for central sewage collection, recycling and reuse of water and clearing up the ponds initially etc were drawn up. It was also for reuse in agriculture. About to be launched. People supported the project and were ready to give free manual service and their land for establishing the treatment plant free of cost. (They asked us to reduce the labour cost from the Project Estimate.) Alas! The state assembly elections were announced and all new works came to a halt! Govt. changes, priorities change …. Well that is India.

But it has given us a rich experience.

It is a great engineering challenge to clean up all village ponds including use of recycled water for continued reuse on sound engineering principles and hand them over to the villagers to manage.

They will!

Their health will improve. Cattle will be better. It will be a great boost to economy, society and people in terms of income increase and quality of life.

 There are several other items in terms of use of water in rural India and in agricultural sector. Due to limitations of time, let us move to urban domestic and industrial use.



When we consider the big metros, and over 5000 cities and towns, domestic water supply is a serious problem – not just in terms of quality but also in terms of regular availability. Delhi the capital city is no exception. Reasons are manifold: from poor planning to mindless designs to callous maintenance. The so called treated water to the lawns of the palacious buildings in the Lutyen Delhi, will be an illustration as to how primitive we are in waste water recycling and reuse.

In a metro city, typical use of a 5 members household would be about 20,000 litres per month. In cities and towns it will be much less. In the metros the same municipal water or the municipal water or the pumped ground water from the apartment complexes are used for cooking, bathing, toilets, house cleaning and car washing. Assuming the corporation supplied water is really of a potable standard, is it the way to waste it, when most of the city dwellers struggle for water? Now a days I find year round movement of private water supply trucks in most cities. So much is the shortage.

Now what happens to the used water? They are discharged as sewage, either in open channels  or in buried pipes. There are often over flows of sewage from the buried sewage pipes, year round, through manholes.

Most households are ill-equipped to use stored rain water, as they were not originally conceived in the house design. Best use of them without treatment would be for gardens or washing outside the houses. Where in metros and cities can we find houses with lawns, plants or trees? There is a pressure for land and space, understandably due to rocketing prices of real estates.

As far the drinking water, middle class is resorting to water purifiers. Low cost purifiers have been launched by Tatas recently. Also there is an increasing resort to bottled water (costly imitation of the developed countries). For those who talk about climate change issues from the podiums studded with bottled water, I would like to quote some statistics:

Worldwide, nearly 2.7 million tons of plastic is used to bottle water each year.

Making plastic bottles to meet demand for bottled water requires millions of containers of oil annually.

Burning used plastic bottles releases toxic chlorine gas in air and leaves toxic ashes containing heavy metals which pollutes the soil and ground water

Real environmental friendly solution would lie in providing a good quality potable water in the taps, if necessary by a separate plumbing line and use another plumbing line for the supply of clean recycled water for other domestic uses.

In addition the amount of leakages in domestic taps, garden taps in apartment complexes etc is a huge waste. Engineering solutions for reduction of consumption right from the time people open the tap in the morning for brushing their teeth to the time when they go to sleep, are required. Engineers may also take into account the sad fact that we Indians in general lack a civic or public good sense. Of course all solutions cannot be from engineering and technology. There has to be public education through celebrities and also through ‘micro economic’ measures of water charges. Of course, a government can acquire the moral right to charge more for water only when it gives regular, dependable and quality water supply: that primarily comes in the domain of engineering in terms of meticulous planning, design, foresight, quality implementation and above all maintenance which should be built into planning, design, and foresight exercises.



In addition to domestic use, in the urban areas there is a considerable use of water in the public domain. Parks, shopping areas, hotels, restaurants, public toilets, bus stations, railway stations, places of worship etc.

What happens in a typical city has been described beautifully and professionally in a recent article in Hindu, September 11, 2010 by S.Viswanath under the title “Treating the sick water”. It is worth looking at some extracts from the concluding part of the article:

“We need urgent steps to rectify this problem in urban India. Unless a vigilant citizenry demands that their local self – governments take up sewage collection and treatment on high priority we will pay through epidemics such as dengue, chikungunya and malaria, taking lives and debilitating a populace.

Islands of excellence exist. Some apartments and some layouts have very good functioning waste water treatment and reuse plants. But many are simply ‘garbage-in-garbage-out’ systems.

At a larger scale the wastewater treatment plants at Cubbon Park and at Lalbagh in Bangalore are almost state – of the – art and one simply cannot make out the treated wastewater as sewage.

The need of the hour is to invest enough attention in collecting every drop of sewage generated from the city, convey it to decentralized wastewater treatment plants, treat them to high standards and release or reuse them as appropriate”.

Wastewater recycling and repeated reuse alone can solve the water and health problems of urban India.

At this point I would like to mention a few words about the Cubbon Park and Lalbagh in Bengaluru referred to above. The engineering expert deeply involved in these projects is Dr.R.Venkataraman former Chief Engineer ISRO. He did them post – retirement from ISRO, at Bengaluru and several plants at Hyderabad.

But the linkage to these plants was way back to his ISRO days. When Prof.Dhawan was Chairman, ISRO, the ISRO Satellite Centre (ISAC) needed (during 1984) additional water of about 0.5 mld than allotted to them by the water supply authorities, who had released the quota for ISAC as per norms. Instead of trying to use governmental pressures (as is the usual mode we all adopt even today!) ISRO chose a method of engineering solution. Dr.Venkataraman gave the design for recycling the waste water from ISAC and the reuse was primarily for use in gardening, landscape maintenance etc. Mr.R.D.John, Chief Engineer supported it. ISRO top management agreed to the novel idea. Water use goes up as organizations grows. So it was expanded to 1 mld during 1988, with some additional design features of secondary treatment with pressure filters, disinfection etc. To get the water source, additional sewage water from NAL (then National Aeronautics Laboratory) in whose campus ISAC was located, was obtained! The recycled water was used for several other internal uses in ISAC including toilet flushing and cooling water for central AC plant. . The plant is functioning even now. ISRO adopted such systems for a few other ISRO centres as well.

It is the outgrowth of these experiences and of course continual learning and application by Dr.R.Venkataraman, led to his building the state – of – art Lalbagh and Cubbon Park plants which are about 1.5 mld.

 Many of you present here and not present here can make wonders to urban India, if you all and IE crusade for proper urban water planning: for separating storm water channels and sewage channels and more importantly by establishing several sewage / wastewater recycling plants and facilities for the repeated reuse of the water.

City should almost be self – sufficient with only about 25% of fresh water coming from surface and ground water sources and the rest coming from recycling. Not a difficult target for our capable engineers.



Many of the huge water consuming industries need to bring down their consumption. Compared to the international standards of water consumption, we are very poor in most industries. This is an urgent task.

Simultaneously wastewater recycling and reuse is a must.

Even those who cannot reuse for various reasons have to let out only the clean recycled water (either collectively – a few small medium industries together or individually).

May I suggest that some of you approach the management of big industries located in and around Bangalore to help them audit their water use and also their recycling capability.

Let us not get into escapism of saying that there are pollution control boards etc. We all know the reality. As engineering professionals we should avoid the cynical acceptance of a situation for which there are sound and cost effective engineering solutions.



If we tackle the above mentioned areas described above such as rural use, agricultural users, urban domestic users, urban public use and industries, we would have solved the immediate water problems of India and also improve health of people. And also the income levels of many rural Indians will increase, thus giving a special boost to the Indian economy. The real market size can go to 1.2 billion unlike the present one which is half of it or less as rest of them are just subsisting.



There are many more items, I cannot cover here. Therefore I would mention some of them. There are areas of India which have brackish water, or water with arsenic, fluoride etc. There has been a lot of talk on them, R & D papers etc. for several decades. But ground solutions are eluding. Many of you know the reasons. They require practical and urgent solutions. People living in such areas suffer.

Desalination is another area which is talked about, sometimes hyped. If waste water reuse on the lines suggested above are adopted on a large scale, pressure for desalination will not be high even for coastal cities. It may be needed in select places where other solutions may not be easily implementable. Also in terms of ecological balance including marine life, I am not sure whether a large scale resort to desalinated water from sea can be sustainable solution.

Interlinking of Rivers is another complex issue. To adopt it as a panacea is ridden with many engineering, sociological and ecological issues. Small scale interlinking locally may be attractive for a few areas.

Use of big rivers for internal Water Ways can be attractive proposition as it is very energy efficient. There is a full fledged study by TIFAC as a part of its Technology Vision 2020 exercise.

These are some of the engineering challenges. Also there are a number of areas attractive for R & D both in terms of commercial prospects as well as social good. Amongst the several pragmatic and immediate – to – implement items mentioned in this brief address, R & D in select topics will also require attention, as future new engineering ventures will emerge out of them.

In the world governed by Word Trade Organisation (WTO) regimes, engineers need to be aware of the legal issues of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR).

IN CONCLUSION: I have galloped through three mega engineering tasks for the engineering community as a whole. They will touch the lives of our people very positively and help the society in many ways. Also most of them will make good business propositions as well, thus contributing to the growth of the economy. Professional commitment and pride are crucial for these to be implemented. May the dreams and actions of Sir M.Visvesvaraya (whose 150th birth anniversary falls this month) and the visionary and practical wisdom of Prof.S.Dhawan (whose 90th birth anniversary fall this month – a unique September) be our guiding lights and inspiring forces.

Engineers have to wake up and jump out of their routine grooves to create a positive dynamism all round.

Thank you.



 Some units used relating to volume of Water:

1 Cubic Metre equal to 35.315 cubic feet; 1 Kilolitre; 1000 litres

1 Hectare metre (ha m) equal to 8.10 Acre ft; 10,000 Cubic metre;

1 Cubic Metre equal to 1 Billion Cubic Meter (BCM); 109  m3; 0.1 million ham (M ham)







Y S Rajan

(to be delivered at First Global Tibetan Professional Summit on 5-6 September 2010 at Dharmashala)



Your Excellency Prime Minister Prof Samdhong Rinpoche, you are an erudite  scholar as well, Your Excellency Kalon Tempa Tsering, Madam Youdon Ankatsang, Executive Director, Envision and other eminent participants

It is indeed a great honour for me to participate in this First Summit and deliver a talk in the presence of holy and enlightened persons and also addressing a wonderful community of Tibetan professionals spread around different parts of the world.

When many critical events took place in Tibet, I was a teenager.  I used to get some filtered information in the Bombay  newspapers. In the geography books, Pamir plateau used to be highlighted.  Later when I grew up, I learnt a lot more about Tibet and its people.  But still I am aware that my knowledge is extremely limited.

While noting the rich historical traditions of Tibet and the current existential realities which are continuing for over five decades, it is a daunting task to envision some broad contours of a future for those persons whose roots are traced to Tibet but who live in different parts of the world. Most of the young and middle aged professionals would not have visited the land of their roots.  Imageries of Tibet and its traditions are available to them only through written and spoken words and occasional audio visual materials brought out of Tibet by foreigners.

A question as to whether they will be able to visit the lands of their roots and as to how they will feel then, is one of most difficult one to answer.  One can only paint scenarios  which can range from cold analysis with lots of pessimism or cynicism on one extreme to various possibilities in the middle range with many ifs and buts, to fictions of optimistic imaginations.  Attempts in that direction itself can be a part of the knowledge and creative industry in which the Global Tibetan professionals (GTP) could be profitably engaged in, if done in moderation.



My inability to create such scenarios can easily be understood.  Therefore I attempt to address a future for the Global Tibetan Professionals (GTP) with the following factors in mind:-

a)THE COLLECTIVE: The Global Tibetan Professional Community (GTPC) will continue to exist for several more decades with its own distinct identity, though they are spread around the world.  Modern information and Communication Technologies (ICT) would help in a great way to have near daily contacts between them, thus strengthening the intracommunity bonds..  Also Tibetans are well known all over the world and welcome in most parts of the world especially due to the compassionate message spread by H.H. Dalai Lama.  There could be some small intermingling of other peoples in this community due to inter-marriage or adoption.   More importantly there would  be some syncretic adaptation with local communities. Therefore all the persons of the GTPC will not be in one single mould.  There will be a rich texture of global realities and global opportunities in their daily lives.  But the fact of keeping the community identity through several forums such as this summit as well as the use of modern fast transportation systems, will also preserve many parts of the rich heritage of Tibet.  One should bear in mind that this rich and hoary heritage is the real GLOBAL BRAND OF TIBET, symbolized of H.H. Dalai Lama and other venerable Tibetan monks.  One of the beneficial action, therefore, of GTPC should be to capture this heritage and display it in various parts of the world they live in.

Wherever they live in or whatever profession they are engaged in, all those who belong to GTPC should have some quality time allotted to this task – that is to keep up the community brand with adequate empathy with other peoples of the world.  It is a universal message from a particular community.

b)THE INDIVIDUALS: Even while the community identity is an important and strong factor for GTPC, being professionals living in different countries, there is also an equally strong force of individual choices.  Some may like to be engineers, some may want to be medical doctors or researchers or bankers or financiers, lawyers or some media persons or some architects or some artists or some in business management.  The GTP network website lists a whole set of them.   It is natural and understandable.  Such individual aspirations will,  to a large extent, have to be realized within the framework of opportunities available in the countries they live in. 

This reality makes it difficult to project a generalized broad brush vision for the future of GTPC’s activities.  When countries like Japan, Korea, Malaysia or Singapore project their vision for a future, or when we did the major national wide exercise Technology Vision for India 2020 through the organisation called Technology Information, Forecasting and assessment Council (TIFAC), assumptions can be made about some normative goals and develop the vision around it.  For example, rate of growth GDP can be assumed to around a band of rate of growth either desired or projected; some assumptions can be made about per capita food requirements etc.,  Since the GTPC does not live within a specific geographic area broadly under its control, it is difficult to make such normative assumptions.

An ideal method would be to capture the aspirations of and opportunities for the GTPC individuals living in different clusters in the world.  Then try to find in them the interconnections and common features.  That could  be a common vision.  On that can be superposed various new emerging global opportunities due to new technologies, businesses, and educational systems.  Some interactive studies can result in a Vision 2020 or 2030 that can be adopted by members of GTPC and for Tibetan Diaspora as a whole.



Vision is not a corporate plan; not should it be a Government Document.  It should be a challenging for the best of minds and yet inclusively realistic to attract the average.  In the following, I have attempted to outline eight mega tasks which collectively form a vision for the GTP’s.

In the  interim, I would suggest the following possibilities of technologies, business and other socio-cultural impacts of global developments on the lives of GTPC and how GTPC can use them to the optimal interest of GTPC and other persons from Tibetan Diaspora.  While doing do I have made an intuitive integration of the two elements, the COLLECTIVE of the GTPC and the INDIVIDUALS of the GTPC with the third element, namely, the newly emerging global opportunities in different parts of the world. These are not exhaustive lists but have been filtered judiciously through the integrative process referred to above.  I believe this listing will be useful in undertaking the major VISION 2020/2030 of GTPC suggested earlier.


Under this category I list various forms of literature, multimedia, cinema, music, art, dances, holistic well being life style practices, etc.,  While computers, audio engineering, visual arts, imaging technologies etc., will be utilized in this field, all these efforts should draw upon the rich Tibetan heritage of the past as well as its manifestation during the  recent times through H.H. Dalai Lama and other venerable monks and teachers who have made their mark in the world during the past 50 years.  Successful integration of these elements into the local cultures of the places in which GTP’s live can be the foundation of a thriving service industry.  It is not necessary that these industries, enterprises or academic studies or other efforts have to be exclusively done  with GT professionals or persons who trace their roots to Tibet.  They should however be the lead persons in terms of original creators or promoters or those who are CEO’s/COO’s/CTO’s etc.,


As distinct from technological research and development, some of the GTP’s may focus on fundamental and basic research in physics, chemistry, biology, mathematics, astronomy, evolutionary biology, astrophysics, archaeology, earth sciences, neuro sciences etc.,  Well, one may ask a question as to what is something special about such areas for GTP’s?  In the whole world so many millions of persons pursue these areas and what is special which a small miniscule community of GTP’s can make some thing different or unique

I think that in addition to the usual rigorous processes of researches in these areas which are common to all, it is possible for GTP persons to make a special mark. I would strongly recommend that all of you read a book by Susantha Goonatilake “Towards a Global Science: Mining Civilisational Knowledge” by Vistaar Publications, New Delhi, 1999.  What I used to experientially feel during my career in science and technology in multicultural settings, he has given a great academic and scholastic foundation.  I consider it as a book of the 21st Century.  The great civilizational knowledge of Tibet and the way in which you are all culturally conditioned by that heritage, will open up new avenues for modern science. It is akin to what a great Indian mathematician Ramanujam did to mathematics.  Even other South Asian scientists subconsciously would have been conditioned.  So I feel that Tibetan culture and heritage may bring something very different in the scientific researches you may pursue. You have to periodically assemble and discuss about such an influence without  being ashamed of it or afraid of.

Even while you follow the narrow confines for the rigor of (Western) modern scientific methods, allow the intuition derived from your heritage to play a role.  I would think a few new Nobel Laureates will emerge from the GTPC, as the world today is ready to look at broader perspectives of life and accept diverse origins.

In order to be effective at a world level, the GT professionals working for such scientific research areas, may like to create a network within themselves.  Try to restrict  the pull of individuality to some extent in order to create a minimum critical size of GTP scientists in a particular domain/area/problem of research.  That will create clusters of GTP presence. Again, this need not be restricted to the exclusive cluster of GTP persons alone.  It may have others from the countries you work in.  It will also help newer ideas and help in citation indices, which are now important for scientific research papers.

If pursued carefully and vigorously by about 2025/2030 impact of GTP’s on some select areas of science may become visible worldwide. What topics/areas, you will choose, I hope, you will select post-this conference through a series of interactions.


Tibetan system of medicine has emerged as one of the alternate  medical system, popular with many persons outside those who have their origins in Tibet.   GTP’s can go well beyond that by researching further using some of modern bio-medical methods.   New science can be brought to the global forums especially through developed countries in which GT professionals live. Creating large chains of Medicare systems, pharma industries, industries of dietary supplements, assistive devices for exercises, etc., may turn out to be a challenging enterprise.  One may target a few billions of turn over in dollars within about a decade say by 2020.

Interesting creative industries supplementing audio/visuals, multimedia etc., for meditation and other such unique Tibetan practices aimed at better physical and mental health, may also become a challenging enterprise.  They could also provide  considerable intellectual challenges to GTP’s.

Brain research and broadly speaking neuroscience researches could be another branch of medical enterprise which hold special promise for the future.  If GT professionals  get into these research fields with some background of Tibetan spiritual and mystic practices, it is likely that by 2020/2030 many new neuro science research findings may emerge, probably revolutionizing the present concepts of cognition, consciousness, evolution etc.,

If a minimum critical clusters of GT professionals concentrate on select items from  the above areas along with partners from the regions in which they live, and yet keep the GTP network alive and active on the lines suggested earlier, Tibetan contributions to modern medical/neuroscience areas can become impact making by 2025/2030.


Let us now consider another important area of scientific activity.  Unlike in the past century, there are now many persons in the developed world (both rich persons as well as intellectual elites) who are ready to accept the possibility of having treasures of knowledge in the wisdom of old persons and old civilizations.  Capturing of traditional knowledge bases has not only become a good (acceptable) academic pursuit but is also seen to be having good commercial potentials.

This task is unlike the Vision 2020/2030  task (1) listed above which was to build TIBETAN BRAND and generate creative industries around it.  Tasks under (1) may not all be scientifically  rigorous or fully factually correct, as they are  meant to be a commercial or infotainment enterprise building on  brands, myths and icons.  The set of tasks meant under this heading (4) are meant to be scientifically  rigorous and academically challenging.  As such one may have to seek research grants from philanthropists and industries who see a long term stakes.  The studies have to be academically and scientifically rigorous while deriving information from ageing persons of Tibetan Diaspora.  The approach should be that of using a  â€œVaccuum Cleaner”.  That is, suck in whatever is available using audio, visual and multimedia.  If there are physical artifacts  or manuscripts available, capture them too.  It is not necessary that all that is talked by the old persons (men and women) and also others in different age groups who are ready to talk, have to be scientifically correct or academically rigorous.  The researchers should be able to capture as much as possible from them and sieve out later.   It is quite possible that industries/ business houses which support these efforts may like to have exclusive Intellectual Property Rights (IPR’s) on some of them.  Well, one has to adapt to the forces of modern market economics and capture as much as possible the knowledge of persons before they disappear from our midst. It is a great  challenge for GTP’s in terms of organizing such an effort, getting funding and get going fast.


Though this can be considered also as a subject of the creative industries using Tibetan Brand that is Vision 2020/2030 Task (1) I am placing it in a specific form which can make a great adventure, great business and a great integration of science, technology, arts, music, geography etc., (a truly multidisciplinary mix)

Modern satellite based remote sensing nowadays not only provides very high resolution pictures but also gives information on undulations of the terrain (like Cartosat data from Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO)).  These data can be integrated with variety of other Geographical Information Systems (GIS). These integrated packages can have other sets of imageries – still pictures, video pictures taken in Tibet and nearby areas as well as inside the holy places, market places etc., superimposed on them.   The modern computer simulation methods of Virtual Reality can be used to develop a whole series of packages which can make the “viewer” go through various parts of Tibet in the virtual world.  Audio commentaries can give descriptions.  Chanting during particular rituals or functions can make the “viewer” to be a participant.  Those who are specialists in virtual reality will understand these processes.

Such packages can help to recapture the vivid imageries of Tibet for those who have their roots traced to those places but cannot visit personally.  Also it can be a great attraction for those who are interested in Tibet.

Even if some day in the future, it becomes easier to visit Tibet, these virtual reality packages can become a training ground for adventurous tourists and even serious researchers and scholars.

Those who do these virtual reality packages on Tibet may add Kailash, Mana Sarovar, Sikkim monastries etc., as an add on to increase the market for these packages.

If a project is started now, within about 5 years one can have excellent series of “Virtual reality” packages of Tibet becoming a major business.

Later the same set of developers and entrepreneurs can do it for other parts of the world, like Alps, Artic, Antarctic etc.,

Raising of funds for data collection, R&D and marketing is not an easy task.  Can GTP’s take it as a challenge and bank on the good will created so far to raise funds? Or make it a part of a big business group, who will then profit from it.


So far I had dealt with items in which groups of a few or several individuals can join and create a research group or R&D or a business.  They are not necessarily small items after they are  completed and later scaled up into major businesses or a scholastic or research endeavor or a service industry.  But initial start can be done with fractions of or a few or several tens of millions of dollars and further investments can be attracted after  successful demonstrations.

But some of GTP’s may at an individual or group level may like to have much bigger challenges, such  as space travel, building up new fusion power plant or a major project in defence or security.  But these projects are huge, requiring several billions of dollars.  Moreover such “big science” projects are still largely dependent on governments.  Even private sector efforts depend on government purchase of goods and services. Therefore I am not including them as a possibility, though I mention it as an item for the sake of completeness. 

So to a question as to the possibility of one of the Global Tibetan being in space for a long duration, the answer is difficult. While one cannot rule it out, one cannot visualize it as a tangible vision of GTP’s.

It is quiet possible that some of the GTP’s may participate in scientific researches like astronomy, planetary sciences, solar system studies etc., and also in plasma physics concerning fusion power.’’ Perhaps we may have to leave these to individual choices and contextual opportunities which may exist for some persons living in some countries.


Except for pointing out such  possibilities I am not again emphasizing or highlighting the following possibilities.

- Can a new music band arise out GTP’s causing ripples in the world as rock bands did at some stage of history?

- Can a new wave of movies being directed/produced by some persons or groups of GTP’s?

-  What about GTP’s creating a new wave in painting, dance forms etc.,?

One of the main reasons why I do not expand on these is because of my limited knowledge in these areas.  Some others may consider these possibilities and create a vision  2020/2030 task, as I have illustrated for other areas.

Other similar areas needing exploration for ruling out or accepting will be:

-              Can there be a new financial network of institutions created by  GTP’s which can impact world financial systems?

-              Can there be a new architectural school emerging out of GTP’s even over a period two decades or more?

I am mentioning some of these for the sake of completeness and also for others to give some thought to these items before ruling them out as possible direction for GTP’s or creating Vision 2030 tasks.


Another vital  task for GTP’s would be to preserve Tibetan language (I mean along with its script) itself from disappearance over a period of a few decades or more.  At the same time, there is also a need to enable it to evolve for meeting the challenges of the modern world by introducing new vocabulary and also by  making massive presence in the cyber world.

In addition, lots of e-enabled “learn by yourselves Tibetan” modules may have to be authentically introduced.  GTP’s can play a large role in this matter.  It is the very basis of maintaining an exclusive identity of a GTP’s or even GT (Global Tibetans),


The above given suggestions are specific for GTP’s taking into account various  possibilities, potentials as well as possible constraints.  Some of you may be interested in a broad brush vision of the future.  I had given on 12th October 2007 a convocation address at the Bharatidasan University, Thiruchirapalli, Tamil Nadu ( India).  It was for graduating students who were around 21-22 years of age then.  I felt it is good for them to know what next sixty years are going to be and what actions are needed to be  taken by them now!

Good part of it is India-centric as I know India better than I know other countries.  But some of the general trends are derived from what is likely to be world over.  Good one year before the global melt down I have envisioned that India for about next 15 years (i.e. say 2012-2013 and may be 2015) is likely to have a cataclysmic fast growth.  Globally such a cataclysm is likely to be around.  Some countries like India may be growing and some developed countries shrinking rapidly; their cozy assumptions about standards of living and welfare standards are likely to have severe beatings.

Such situations pose special challenges for GTP’s. But their heritage of hardiness and H.H. Dalai Lama’s message of moderation may help them to win over many difficult situations.

I am not elaborating upon further details. I feel it will be good if GTP’s read that address and draw their own versions of next sixty years.  Many of you are still young to dream for sixty years.

The cited address can be seen in my website under the section Articles; it is titled “Next Sixty Years: Actions Now”.

WHAT NEXT?        

We have covered so far, a wide range of possibilities to identify Vision 2020/2030 mega tasks for the future for GTP’s. There are many challenges embedded in them.  Not knowing the exact distribution of GTP’s, in various countries, their interests, resources etc., many of these possibilities do not have  a reality check.

I would therefore suggest that GTP’s consider a number of ideas put forth in my talk, and internally debate about the applicability or otherwise of the ideas in the actual GTP context and their aspirations. If some of the ideas look promising, serious study groups or working groups could be constituted to analyze various scenarios and options.  While committees may operate at an apex level to finalise and decide on the paths for action, at the time of capturing various scenarios and options, it will be better to get inputs from a large cross sections of people even if they were not professionals.  It may also be useful to capture the views of others who are not  of Tibetan origin but are engaged with GTP’s in different parts of the world; that will help understanding the perceptions of others.

Modern methods of scenario writing, response to questionnaires, brain storming, select interviews, nominal group techniques etc., will be useful in such processes.  Depending on the resources, this exercise  can be big or medium sized.  The findings from such studies can help to arrive at a road map for the future options of GTP’s.  Perhaps this exercise can be conducted in about 6 months. Potential  funders can be approached thereafter for follow up actions.

I have gone through the whole process of national exercise for Vision 2020 for 2 years.  It is a great fun.  You will all enjoy it more because of modern fast ICT’s and inexpensive and speedy transport. If GTP’s have an event a year from now, then this road map  could be declared as Vision 2025/2030  ROADMAP for Global Tibetans.   A brief write up for large scale (popular) dissemination will be useful as a public information material.  In addition, detailed reports are required for specific follow up actions.

I hope I have been able to do some justice to the faith you have reposed on me through your invitation to this august gathering.  I would join in the prayers for a bright future for all of you who are here and other Tibetans who are not present here.

Thank you all


Y.S. Rajan is Dr. Vikram Sarabhai Distinguished Professor, ISRO, Bangalore. Views are personal.  Visit website